****Spoilers for season one of Lanterns ****
Kendall Francis, a young Black women LSU college student, accused football player Damien Shanklin of raping her in 2025. LSU found him “responsible for forcible rape” and suspended him for a year. But a female administrative judge, Janet Waguespek overturned Shanklin’s suspension as “exceedingly harsh” since he was a first-time offender and this was “an error in judgment” rather than a rape “with malice.” Thanks to Judge Janet, victims all over the world learned that there was a way to forcibly rape “without malice.” Shanklin was given a literal slap on the wrist probation sentence and allowed to presume college life and sports without consequences. The kicker, though, was that when Francis told Shanklin after the forcible rape that she was going to the hospital for a rape kit and wanted to “end [her] life,” his mother “contacted the woman and asked her ‘not to do anything to jeopardize [Shanklin’s] career.’”
This is how women uphold patriarchy. This, my friends, is a Boy Mom.
More than just a “mother of sons,” a boy mom centers the boy’s public success in the world over everything and everyone—even at the expense of her own son’s well-being.
The DCU show Lanterns has boy moms on full display in episode three of its first season. After the episode aired a few weeks back, I wrote about the disappointing portrayal of a Black mother who would raise her Black son to be emotionless by putting him in horrifically abusive situations and teaching him to ignore his human response to it. Bernadette (Jasmine Cephas Jones) is raising a monster in John Stewart (Aaron Pierre), but the ends justify the means.
The ends in this instance are John becoming a Green Lantern intergalactic superhero. The Guardians passed over his father John Sr. (J. Alphonse Nicholson) because he was afraid. They promised Bernadette if she raised John to be fearless, he would not be passed up, and she obliged. He became a puppet and killing machine of the white supremacist U.S. government, setting him up perfectly to be a puppet and killing machine of the alien supremacist intergalactic Guardians. Whoever he killed or destroyed to reach that goal was not on Bernadette’s mind. She would make her son a Green Lantern and then…what?
Her character is too poorly and shallowly written to understand. I thought perhaps by the end of the season we might get some answers as to why she chose this path for her son and why she took such psychotic and cruel measures starting when he was five years old in order for him to achieve it. But no. We should just assume that it makes sense for a Black mother to directly and physically torture her Black child into success instead of just indirectly doing it by sending him to an all-white school in the suburbs like a regular upwardly mobile Black mother. (Nikole Hannah-Jones notwithstanding, I guess.)
When John returns home after taking up the Green Lantern mantle as an independent contractor and not an agent of the state, he hugs his mother the longest of anyone in his family, and she, after seeing him wear the Green Lantern ring, finally exhales. I rolled my eyes waiting for Whitney to come back and sing “Shoop.”
Because what do you mean?
This idea of Bernadette “holding her breath” every time she tortured her son because she loved him and wanted the best for him even though she was hurting him comes up when John is trying to make an excuse for Hal’s murder. Earth’s original Green Lantern, Hal (Kyle Chandler), has spent the season being in love with Rushville’s town sheriff, Kerry (Kelly MacDonald). When he discovers her secret—that she’s lied to both Hal and John the entire time she’s known them about her now-teenage son Noah, who is a Manhunter—he tries to help her and her son escape. But she doesn’t want to leave Rushville and go to Guadalajara as he suggests, so she shoots him dead in the head.
But the show decides that she’s just a boy mom trying to protect her little murderbot, and they write this as sympathetic. Even as the mothers become monsters themselves.
“You must’ve been holding your breath for Noah his whole life just like my own psycho mom!” (paraphrasing,) John sympathizes with Kerry, relating her raising an actual weapon of mass destruction to a Black mother raising a Black son in America. In my loudest Dick Gregory voice: AND Y’ALL LIKE THIS SHIT?!?!
Just because some writers on the show were Black doesn’t mean they can’t also spit in your face and this entire show is a spit in the face—from the casting of the British Aaron Pierre and his god-awful Black American imitation crab meat accent (Seriously, if Pierre was the best actor for the job, just make the character British and spare us all! But I maintain that he wasn’t, because J. Alphonse Nicholson, who, much like his character in the show, was passed over for the role and relegated to play John Sr. instead, was right there!), to the absolute butchering of a portrayal of what it means to raise Black children in America.
Even as an allegory, raising a Black child to be emotionless is trash and anti-Black. The problem isn’t our fear! The problem is systemic white supremacy! Eliminating fear doesn’t stop the bullets from coming! What an ignorant idea! That a Black mother would drop her Black son off in the ‘hood at night to build fearlessness and tell him to find his way home, when if she was really ‘bout that life, she would’ve dropped him off in a white neighborhood and called the cops; That a Black mother would instruct a Black father to shoot apples off her child’s head to make him not afraid of bullets; That a Black mother—whose deepest fears are of her children being monsterized and gunned down by police—would instead build a monster from scratch.
The show wants us to believe that Hal and his actual Green Lantern successor Guy Gardner are the racist ones, making racial microaggressions to John and passing them off as jokes. And they are racist. But the real anti-Blackness is in the writing and colorist casting of John, who is dark-skinned in the comics; and the lack of writing of his mother, father and brothers with any depth or truth. Let’s throw in an OutKast song here, and tell Pierre to say AXS instead of ASK, is that Black American enough for you?!
It’s egregious that John is so removed from the Black American experience that he doesn’t see Kerry as a sheriff shooting an unarmed civilian in cold blood. He sees her as a poor little scared boy mom just trying to protect her little Timmy from threats Hal never even made. When police killing unarmed Black people in cold blood because they’re “scared” is literally the foundation of the latest Black civil rights movement in this country, this is the storyline that Damon Lindelof and Vanessa Baden Kelly and Tom King, and Chris Mundy and Justin Britt-Gibson and Breannah Gibson chose to write and have John sympathize with? I am disgusted.
Upon confessing to John, Kerry offers to turn herself into herself, I guess, as the sheriff—as soon as she finishes watching Noah play in the big football game and choose a college team. But John turns her down. Hal wouldn’t want her to go to prison for his murder. Nobody came to his funeral because nobody cares about Hal anyway besides John, so why should Kerry face any consequences?
At minimum, she can’t even be asked to step down from being the sheriff? Just like her Manhunter son, she is a literal danger to anyone around her, even the people she claimed to love. But, no. You keep on being you, Sheriff Kerry. After all, she only became sheriff to protect the original Manhunter in town, and now that the only one left is her son, she has double the justification to be in charge. Never mind that her son is leaving town to play football in college, she still must remain sheriff because she’s earned it, I guess. And hey, John murdered the murderbot’s grandma who was about to murder Hal and get the whole town blown up, so it’s only fair that Kerry gets to murder her boyfriend in cold blood for no reason too. Let’s call it even.
And the show wants us to feel good about this ending.
“Was it worth it?” is a recurring question that the betrayed ask their betrayers on this show. The show wants us to believe it was. In the end, the music swells, John and a projection of Hal get to say their “I love yous” and goodbyes; and John warmly (and unrealistically) reunites with his Black family, despite the fact that he’s been fighting with his brothers over the phone the whole show with no resolution to their previous problems.
And most egregious of all, there’s no scene of John confronting Bernadette or John Sr. for how they raised him; for what they took from him of his own humanity trying to make him a Green Lantern. It’s just acceptance and understanding and warm fuzzy feelings, Hal’s alien venus fly trap nestled safely on the shelf in the Stewart family home. Noah also has no confrontation with his mother, he just tries to take responsibility for Hal’s murder to protect her. Literally, this “kid” has already broken the baddest intergalactic criminal out of prison and made him forge a lantern and ring powerful enough for Noah to kill a Guardian, but he felt bad about it and wants to be a good boy now so let’s forget all that. It’s just John and Noah, fighting their monster programming together, against the world.
The two villainous mothers leave season one vindicated. All their sacrifices (murder, on Kerry’s part) and hard work to create and protect monsters has paid off because their boys are safe. Mind you, the world isn’t—John waterboarded an unarmed prisoner and let a trigger-happy sheriff off the hook for the murder of his partner all in one episode. And Noah is off to a densely populated city to play football in college while fighting his natural urge to HUNT PEOPLE. But Monsters’ Lives Matter or whatever this show with its terrible, insulting politics is trying to say.
But when you make copaganda starring a Black person that also needs to appeal to a majority white audience to keep the lights on, what can you expect?
Stay watchin’,
Brooke
Enjoyed this piece? Tip your writer!

Leave a Reply