She’s an award-winning filmmaker AND award-winning film critic! On Friday, November 6 at the opening ceremony of the Black Harvest Film Festival in Chicago, my directorial debut feature film ABANITU: A Family Documentary received the Sandor Prize Honorable Mention for Feature Film! Hosted at the Gene Siskel Film Center, the Festival screened ABANITU to …
Author: Brooke Obie
-

Horror Week: ‘Get Out’: When Black Women’s Fear Reads As Jealousy
So, Halloween is over, it’s now November (GO VOTE TODAY!!), but the veil is still thin! So, Horror Week continues for one more day, with a final look at the last film in Jordan Peele’s (current) canon, his Oscar-winning directorial debut and most critically acclaimed film, Get Out.
I saw Get Out on opening weekend in early 2017, surrounded by Black peop…
-

Horror Week: Jordan Peele’s ‘Nope’ Explained
Black Horror Week continues with this throwback breakdown of my all-time favorite Jordan Peele film, Nope. I watched it three times in IMAX before I wrote this explainer. It’s one of those films that I think every Black person in Hollywood should watch and reckon with as they make their art. I also just love another opportunity to talk about this film r…
-

Horror Week: The Ending of Jordan Peele’s ‘Us’ Explained
It’s Halloween week! There’s no better time to celebrate Black horror. The genre has had such a resurgence on film since Jordan Peele stepped into his power as an auteur and ‘Us’ is one of my favorites—and one of Peele’s least-appreciated films. While I prepare to direct my latest film this week and process the ridiculous amount of new movies and shows …
-

The Black Girl Revenge Movie We Need Right Now
TW: rape
For the past two weeks, news of the Cornell rapists and the LSU rapist have dominated social media. As is usual under global patriarchy, the institutions of power have conspired to ensure that the rapists at their schools face no real consequences while the victims continue to suffer. It’s no wonder that female rage is palpable.
As humans do, survivors have been looking to art to process their rage, with many suggesting films like Promising Young Woman as a cathartic watch. I could not disagree more. Instead of a dissertation on all the ways that film hates women, I’ll share with you a film that deeply loves Black women specifically, and a conversation with the filmmaker, Ellie Foumbi, whose stunning debut film Our Father, The Devil, is the best movie I’ve ever seen and is the Black girl revenge film we need right now.
Starring the brilliant Babetide Sadjo as Marie and a chilling Soulemayne Sy Savane, Our Father the Devil follows an African refugee whose “quiet existence in a sleepy mountain town in the south of France is upended by the arrival of a charismatic Catholic priest whom she recognizes as the warlord who slaughtered her family.”
In the fifth episode of the Another Possible World podcast, Foumbi shares with me the revolutionary way she crafted this story of Black girl rage, healing and love. I have NEVER seen a film where Black girls get to rage without being shamed or punished (Is God Is, included!) until I saw Our Father the Devil. Bucking the usual propaganda of unjustifiably angry Black girls, Foumbi shares why we need stories like hers and why even in her debut, she chose truth over Hollywood tropes.
Foumbi is one of the most exciting filmmakers I’ve ever had the pleasure to watch; a true and honest visionary whose story of grief is wrapped up in a deep, deep love for Black women and shows us that we can both exist in our fullness, in our rage and in our joy and still be totally loved and cherished. I hope you enjoy our conversation as much as I did.
If you haven’t seen Our Father the Devil, yet, please do yourself a favor and buy it as I did, since you will likely want to rewatch again and again and bawl your eyes out and cocoon yourself in Foumbi’s love. (Buy it here on Apple.)
Stay watchin,’
Brooke
RELATED:
Another Possible World, Ep. 1: It Ends with an Intimacy Coordinator:
Another Possible World, Ep. 2: “How to Make Art with Integrity”
Another Possible World, Ep. 3: “How to Reclaim Our Stories”
Another Possible World, Ep. 4: “How to Start a Revolution”
-

‘Lanterns’ Shows How Boy Moms Make Monsters
****Spoilers for season one of Lanterns ****
Kendall Francis, a young Black women LSU college student, accused football player Damien Shanklin of raping her in 2025. LSU found him “responsible for forcible rape” and suspended him for a year. But a female administrative judge, Janet Waguespek overturned Shanklin’s suspension as “exceedingly harsh” since he was a first-time offender and this was “an error in judgment” rather than a rape “with malice.” Thanks to Judge Janet, victims all over the world learned that there was a way to forcibly rape “without malice.” Shanklin was given a literal slap on the wrist probation sentence and allowed to presume college life and sports without consequences. The kicker, though, was that when Francis told Shanklin after the forcible rape that she was going to the hospital for a rape kit and wanted to “end [her] life,” his mother “contacted the woman and asked her ‘not to do anything to jeopardize [Shanklin’s] career.’”
This is how women uphold patriarchy. This, my friends, is a Boy Mom.
More than just a “mother of sons,” a boy mom centers the boy’s public success in the world over everything and everyone—even at the expense of her own son’s well-being.
The DCU show Lanterns has boy moms on full display in episode three of its first season. After the episode aired a few weeks back, I wrote about the disappointing portrayal of a Black mother who would raise her Black son to be emotionless by putting him in horrifically abusive situations and teaching him to ignore his human response to it. Bernadette (Jasmine Cephas Jones) is raising a monster in John Stewart (Aaron Pierre), but the ends justify the means.
The ends in this instance are John becoming a Green Lantern intergalactic superhero. The Guardians passed over his father John Sr. (J. Alphonse Nicholson) because he was afraid. They promised Bernadette if she raised John to be fearless, he would not be passed up, and she obliged. He became a puppet and killing machine of the white supremacist U.S. government, setting him up perfectly to be a puppet and killing machine of the alien supremacist intergalactic Guardians. Whoever he killed or destroyed to reach that goal was not on Bernadette’s mind. She would make her son a Green Lantern and then…what?
Her character is too poorly and shallowly written to understand. I thought perhaps by the end of the season we might get some answers as to why she chose this path for her son and why she took such psychotic and cruel measures starting when he was five years old in order for him to achieve it. But no. We should just assume that it makes sense for a Black mother to directly and physically torture her Black child into success instead of just indirectly doing it by sending him to an all-white school in the suburbs like a regular upwardly mobile Black mother. (Nikole Hannah-Jones notwithstanding, I guess.)
When John returns home after taking up the Green Lantern mantle as an independent contractor and not an agent of the state, he hugs his mother the longest of anyone in his family, and she, after seeing him wear the Green Lantern ring, finally exhales. I rolled my eyes waiting for Whitney to come back and sing “Shoop.”
Because what do you mean?
This idea of Bernadette “holding her breath” every time she tortured her son because she loved him and wanted the best for him even though she was hurting him comes up when John is trying to make an excuse for Hal’s murder. Earth’s original Green Lantern, Hal (Kyle Chandler), has spent the season being in love with Rushville’s town sheriff, Kerry (Kelly MacDonald). When he discovers her secret—that she’s lied to both Hal and John the entire time she’s known them about her now-teenage son Noah, who is a Manhunter—he tries to help her and her son escape. But she doesn’t want to leave Rushville and go to Guadalajara as he suggests, so she shoots him dead in the head.
But the show decides that she’s just a boy mom trying to protect her little murderbot, and they write this as sympathetic. Even as the mothers become monsters themselves.
“You must’ve been holding your breath for Noah his whole life just like my own psycho mom!” (paraphrasing,) John sympathizes with Kerry, relating her raising an actual weapon of mass destruction to a Black mother raising a Black son in America. In my loudest Dick Gregory voice: AND Y’ALL LIKE THIS SHIT?!?!
Just because some writers on the show were Black doesn’t mean they can’t also spit in your face and this entire show is a spit in the face—from the casting of the British Aaron Pierre and his god-awful Black American imitation crab meat accent (Seriously, if Pierre was the best actor for the job, just make the character British and spare us all! But I maintain that he wasn’t, because J. Alphonse Nicholson, who, much like his character in the show, was passed over for the role and relegated to play John Sr. instead, was right there!), to the absolute butchering of a portrayal of what it means to raise Black children in America.
Even as an allegory, raising a Black child to be emotionless is trash and anti-Black. The problem isn’t our fear! The problem is systemic white supremacy! Eliminating fear doesn’t stop the bullets from coming! What an ignorant idea! That a Black mother would drop her Black son off in the ‘hood at night to build fearlessness and tell him to find his way home, when if she was really ‘bout that life, she would’ve dropped him off in a white neighborhood and called the cops; That a Black mother would instruct a Black father to shoot apples off her child’s head to make him not afraid of bullets; That a Black mother—whose deepest fears are of her children being monsterized and gunned down by police—would instead build a monster from scratch.
The show wants us to believe that Hal and his actual Green Lantern successor Guy Gardner are the racist ones, making racial microaggressions to John and passing them off as jokes. And they are racist. But the real anti-Blackness is in the writing and colorist casting of John, who is dark-skinned in the comics; and the lack of writing of his mother, father and brothers with any depth or truth. Let’s throw in an OutKast song here, and tell Pierre to say AXS instead of ASK, is that Black American enough for you?!
It’s egregious that John is so removed from the Black American experience that he doesn’t see Kerry as a sheriff shooting an unarmed civilian in cold blood. He sees her as a poor little scared boy mom just trying to protect her little Timmy from threats Hal never even made. When police killing unarmed Black people in cold blood because they’re “scared” is literally the foundation of the latest Black civil rights movement in this country, this is the storyline that Damon Lindelof and Vanessa Baden Kelly and Tom King, and Chris Mundy and Justin Britt-Gibson and Breannah Gibson chose to write and have John sympathize with? I am disgusted.
Upon confessing to John, Kerry offers to turn herself into herself, I guess, as the sheriff—as soon as she finishes watching Noah play in the big football game and choose a college team. But John turns her down. Hal wouldn’t want her to go to prison for his murder. Nobody came to his funeral because nobody cares about Hal anyway besides John, so why should Kerry face any consequences?
At minimum, she can’t even be asked to step down from being the sheriff? Just like her Manhunter son, she is a literal danger to anyone around her, even the people she claimed to love. But, no. You keep on being you, Sheriff Kerry. After all, she only became sheriff to protect the original Manhunter in town, and now that the only one left is her son, she has double the justification to be in charge. Never mind that her son is leaving town to play football in college, she still must remain sheriff because she’s earned it, I guess. And hey, John murdered the murderbot’s grandma who was about to murder Hal and get the whole town blown up, so it’s only fair that Kerry gets to murder her boyfriend in cold blood for no reason too. Let’s call it even.
And the show wants us to feel good about this ending.
“Was it worth it?” is a recurring question that the betrayed ask their betrayers on this show. The show wants us to believe it was. In the end, the music swells, John and a projection of Hal get to say their “I love yous” and goodbyes; and John warmly (and unrealistically) reunites with his Black family, despite the fact that he’s been fighting with his brothers over the phone the whole show with no resolution to their previous problems.
And most egregious of all, there’s no scene of John confronting Bernadette or John Sr. for how they raised him; for what they took from him of his own humanity trying to make him a Green Lantern. It’s just acceptance and understanding and warm fuzzy feelings, Hal’s alien venus fly trap nestled safely on the shelf in the Stewart family home. Noah also has no confrontation with his mother, he just tries to take responsibility for Hal’s murder to protect her. Literally, this “kid” has already broken the baddest intergalactic criminal out of prison and made him forge a lantern and ring powerful enough for Noah to kill a Guardian, but he felt bad about it and wants to be a good boy now so let’s forget all that. It’s just John and Noah, fighting their monster programming together, against the world.
The two villainous mothers leave season one vindicated. All their sacrifices (murder, on Kerry’s part) and hard work to create and protect monsters has paid off because their boys are safe. Mind you, the world isn’t—John waterboarded an unarmed prisoner and let a trigger-happy sheriff off the hook for the murder of his partner all in one episode. And Noah is off to a densely populated city to play football in college while fighting his natural urge to HUNT PEOPLE. But Monsters’ Lives Matter or whatever this show with its terrible, insulting politics is trying to say.
But when you make copaganda starring a Black person that also needs to appeal to a majority white audience to keep the lights on, what can you expect?
Stay watchin’,
Brooke
-

‘Primetime’ Targets the Wrong Villains, ‘Digger’ Argues That Art Still Matters, ‘Verity’ Proves Dakota Johnson Is Trolling Us
Trigger Warning: commentary on pedophilia, rape.
Primetime Targets the Wrong Villains
Imagine a country where genocide, rape and enslavement of children are so foundational that 250 years later, it still has a president that’s openly guilty of all three. Imagine that there are files—millions of pages of files—with this president’s name on them, filled with detailed and credible accusations of child rape and pedophilia. Imagine we didn’t even need the files to prove this because this president bragged about barging into his female teen employees’ dressing rooms to catch children while undressed. Now imagine that president started an entire war with Iran to prevent the details of him being a child predator from coming to light.
Now imagine that—in the middle of this child predator’s anti-Arab war of distraction— Lance Oppenheim premieres a film about the early 2000s NBC Dateline show To Catch a Predator focused not on catching predators but on how the host Chris Hansen was a megalomaniac who was obsessed with ratings.
You see how this looks, right?
Starring a chilling Robert Pattinson as Hansen, the highly-stylized A24 flick Primetime follows his spiral as he tries to up the ante on the show in order to compete with the ABC megahit Lost in the Wednesday night primetime slot. “They’ve got a polar bear!” Hansen whines while watching a great episode from the show. So Hansen needed a whale. A big fish, high-profile predator sloppy enough to get caught in the show’s devious web of adult producers and actors pretending to be children. Hansen disregards his female lead producer (a wicked Merritt Weaver) and manipulates an emerging actor (Skyler Gisondo) on his road to ratings glory.
Was To Catch a Predator copaganda that made police look like heroes who solve crimes? Yes. Did one of the hunted child predators—who was also a district gotdamn attorney—die by suicide to avoid facing the consequences of child pornography being found on his hard drive during a raid Hansen set up with the police? Sure did. Is reality TV a cesspool where heartless producers thrive? Obviously. Was Hansen a shitty, absent dad, a cheating husband and a toxic boss while also hunting predators? Allegedly!
But Lance, I’m going to hold your hand with a napkin between us when I tell you: none of what Hansen is accused of is worse than being a child predator. So what exactly do you want me to do with this information that Hansen sucks?
“What would have happened if I wasn’t here?” Pattinson’s Hansen asks the question in his final scene. Hansen usually reserves this question for the end of a confrontation with a predator, except this final time, he asks it through tears, presumably full of guilt and shame at what he’s set in motion for a predator to befall before the screen cuts to black. I’ll tell you what would’ve happened: the district attorney would’ve continued to have child sexual abuse material on his hard drive. He would’ve continued to try and meet children online. He would’ve harmed children. And if he worked real hard and put his mind to it, he could’ve been President of the United States one day.
If I was supposed to cry and feel guilty with Hansen by the end of the film, I’m simply not the audience. More dead child predators, I say.
But who is the audience for this?
When zero people from the Epstein files have been held accountable in America; when Trump is literally making it easier for rapists to thrive on college campuses by gutting Title IX just this week; when he’s literally been found liable for rape and finally after years of fighting had to pay his victim $5 million and it barely made a blip in the news; while he mass-murders Iranian children to distract us from the fact that he’s a pedophile—which no one with power seems to care enough to do something about anyway!!!—why is Chris Hansen’s copaganda that was actually catching child predators the topic to make a movie about in 2026? Why this film on this topic and why now? Understanding context and who is served by this film are crucial to media literacy.
“People can say that this isn’t traditional journalism, or that we were working too closely with the police, which are both valid for discussion,” Hansen told Mel Magazine in 2020. But in the end, we preserved the legal cases, served social justice and moved the enterprise journalism needle forward.”
Cops don’t deliver justice to victims; most predators don’t ever see a lick of accountability for their harm. When pedophiles literally run the world, I’m not going to strain my neck worrying about whether the guy who stopped nearly 350 of them—pediatricians, lawyers, teachers, rabbis, sunday school teachers, youth counselors, fathers!— used unethical practices to catch the predators.
Bring down the global pedophile cabal in the Epstein files. Then we can circle back on whether Chris Hansen was an unethical jerk. Until then, I’m changing the channel on Primetime.
Digger Argues That Art Still Matters
Don’t let the bad reviews fool you. Alejandro G. Iñárritu is a genius and Digger is his opus. On the surface, Digger is about a Texas oil tycoon named Digger Rockwell whose insatiable greed and moral depravity leads to a climate catastrophe. Played by Tom Cruise (who’s probably having more fun than he did jumping out of airplanes in Mission Impossible), Digger flips the “save the cat” trope on its head; his dedication to keep alive a decrepit dying cat is not evidence of his humanity, but of his unwillingness to accept inconvenient truths. He tortuously keeps the cat alive just as he keeps drilling for oil in Greenland against his environmentalists’ severe warnings and evidence of death and destruction.
Iñárritu films it as a farce, with gratuitous use of close-up, distorted lens shots of the villainous white American men who are destroying our planet. A fascinating, circus-like score from Cosmo Sheldrake punctuates their choices to doom us all to hell. The immaculate production design bring the farce-within-a-farce to life. After his first opus Birdman, I’d call Digger the ultimate proof that Iñárritu is the master of meta filmmaking. And uncomfortably prescient, writing about an ice shelf detaching from a glacier due to man-made climate change, and American oil tycoons in cahoots with the president colonizing Greenland nine years before Trump and his cronies actually tried it.
I don’t blame the doubters; when the film double-axles into its first twist, I was totally taken out of the movie. I thought the stakes had been completely deflated and perhaps Iñárritu wasn’t committing to the bit and therefore thought I shouldn’t either. Me of little faith. The complaints about the satire not going far enough ignore what’s underneath. Twist after twist make clear that the commitment of Digger is not simply to a skewering of the billionaire class of white American men whose powers combine to destroy the planet. This is a film about the power of art to heal, to grieve, to rage against our reality when we feel hopeless.
Digger is a profound wrestling match wherein Iñárritu wonders aloud whether art in the face of catastrophe is worth it. Why do we bother with craft when the world is falling apart? How many disaster films have already been made with no end to the climate catastrophe in sight? How many sci-fi films warning about the evils of A.I. have been used as blueprints for the evil tech overlords to build the tools necessary to destroy us all? How many millions loved The Matrix in 1999 only to be rendered completely useless when ChatGPT goes down for a few hours? WHAT ARE WE DOING? WHY DO WE BOTHER? IS ANYONE OUT THERE LISTENING?! When all the artist can do is punch up at power with our tiny collective fist while nothing has changed for the better, and fearfully, nothing ever will, what is the point?
Iñárritu argues that art is the point. That even as billionaires rape and plummet the earth of her resources, wipe out millions of people and billions of life forms with their insatiable greed; as the Ellisons gut the film industry with aims of making its zionist white supremacist propaganda, like Yellowstone, Fauda, and CSI:Whereverthefck while replacing us all with robots; Iñárritu argues that it is still worthwhile to make the art. That a change happens in us when we make it. A change happens in us when we consume it collectively. That processing our rage, grief, fear, and love through art together still matters—even if we immediately re-enter our current hellscape when we leave the theater. That it may actually be all we have left in the end.
The world has ended several times before and will again. And after it all, we who survive will continue to do art. The desperate artist in me clings to that message in these desperate times with both hands. Whether this film is worth it, my answer is a resounding yes.
But I do have a few notes. When a white woman outside of my screening at the Academy asked me what the event was for, and I yelled back at her, “Digger!” and her eyes went wide, I thought, yeah, they probably could’ve changed the title of this one. And my girl Sandra Hüller (Anatomy of a Fall) and my enby Emma D’Arcy (House of the Dragon) are utterly wasted; this is a movie about evil men, not their victims. But, that’s to be expected. Unlike Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother, which is about a dad, this movie is called Digger and is about Digger. So, manage your expectations and enjoy the funhouse mirror.
******* PAID SUBSCRIBERS CAN WATCH A 45-MINUTE Q&A WITH TOM CRUISE, ALEJANDRO IÑÁRRITU, JOHN GOODMAN, SAUNDRA HÜLLER BELOW:
Verity Proves Dakota Johnson Is Trolling Us
There is a moment about mid-way through the unintentionally hilarious Colleen Hoover adaptation Verity where Dakota Johnson’s Lowen and Josh Hartnett’s Jeremy are on a birthday dinner date. “Are you hating this?” He asks her. “Oh, no, I love this. I’m having a great time.” “Okay, cause I can’t tell,” he responds. “That’s just my face,” Lowen says, as if Johnson is breaking the fourth wall and talking directly to the exasperated audience. “I have resting bored face.” Then it occurred to me: Johnson has been trolling us all along.
Throughout the film, Johnson’s Lowen has been blank and expressionless—even after witnessing a heinous car accident where she is splattered with blood. Just moments before she makes this damning comment, I was cringing aloud: “she is dry as hell!” It’s not unique to this performance or this laughably bad script. She also tanked The Materialists for me, which was already working with an extremely flawed script itself. After countless critiques of her dead-face acting and non-existent range, (this critique is a favorite), Johnson shows no signs of improving—nor desire to improve—and why should she? The studios keep hiring her. With this film, she may just be embracing the criticism and trolling all the way to the bank.
And why not? Her seasonless acting is exactly what a white Tyler Perry / Colleen Hoover adaptation deserves. Still, it’s a shame for Anne Hathaway, who really gives her all in the title role (I know Tyler Perry is jealous he did not think to call a character “Verity” and have her struggle with the truth and what’s real, and then be punished with disability for her wickedness first).
Verity is a true crime novelist who writes best-sellers from the perspective of the villain—and comes dangerously close to being considered one herself. Lowen is the femme fatale hired to live in Verity’s home with her husband and son and ghost write Verity’s book series for her. Hathaway’s never been so deliciously evil and it’s unfortunately wasted on a predictable drivel of a script. You see the twists coming a mile away but it takes almost two hours to do the mile! Distressing. It’s supposed to be campy (I hope!), but I don’t think it was intended to be a comedy. Still, at all the moments where we’re meant to gasp, I literally laughed out loud. It’s a ridiculous disaster of a film. You’ll love it.
Moonlight Is Back in Theaters for the 10th Anniversary
The most beautiful film—my number one for 10 years until Sinners came along— is back in theaters for its 10th anniversary screening. It’s been restored and remastered in 4K and it is perfect. It’s the first film I ever evangelized for, going to the movies TEN TIMES and paying for friends and family to go see it as well. I bawled my eyes out through the credits every single time. It is absolutely perfect—save for one small thing. I will argue down that in the final scene, Kevin and Chiron should’ve kissed in the kitchen. I stand on that as a missed opportunity for tenderness and romance that was well-earned. #RELEASETHEKISSCUT!
One of my favorite memories is of picking up my father from the airport on Thanksgiving morning and driving him straight to the movie theater to watch Moonlight in 2016. We had a breakthrough conversation about masculinity that has continued over the past decade and I’m forever grateful to the brilliance of Tarell Alvin McCraney and Barry Jenkins for this film. Its spiritual successor, If I Go, Will They Miss Me? is also in select theaters. Make it a double feature and deconstruct toxic masculinity and the patriarchy that keeps men and boys from accessing the depths of love and connection.
Stay watchin’,
Brooke
Enjoyed this piece? Tip your writer!
-

‘Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother’ Is About Your Dad
**********Mild spoilers for Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother**********
How many mothers is Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother about? If you guessed zero, you would be correct! This film is about Your Dad and how hard he has it.
This is first evident in the fact that writer-director Bassam Tariq’s film stars a dad, Mahershala Ali. He plays an assassin named Latif, a devout Muslim who cuts down Islamophobic violent enemies with his swords. On the poster for the film, he is rocking his newborn baby girl in a bjorn to show his nurturing side (#girldad!), while also carrying a sword to show his warrior side. A striking image from the beginning of the film is of Latif practicing sword murder techniques in a way that feels spiritual, meditative, as his young son Qadir swings on a swingset in the background. It’s the clearest image of the film that conveys what’s at its core: wrestling with duty, fatherhood and faith. Your mother is irrelevant.
The mysterious mother of Latif’s three children (including a newborn) dies inconveniently off screen a few minutes into the film while Latif is assassinating a bad man who harmed Muslims. Just as he’s wrapping the body up in plastic, Latif gets a call from his teen daughter Fatiha (played by Adia, a bright spot and rising star) letting him know that her mother is dead, leaving a breastfeeding newborn behind. How did the mother die? Why did she die? When did she die? Where did she die? I’ll spoil it, just this once: we’ll never know.
We only learn that her name was Khadijah when the family’s imam (Giancarlo Esposito) tells a story to Fatiha about why her mother chose the name Khadijah. “I thought you chose it for her,” Fatiha remarks to the imam, speaking volumes of how much this young girl has already ingested about the ways that girls and women are expected to bow to the leadership and authority of men—even over matters of self-identification and governance. “No, she chose it herself!” the imam proclaims proudly while telling her the significance of the name.
Khadijah was the first wife of the Prophet Muhammad. I do not know much about Islam but the vibe I got from the way she is described is similar to the Proverbs 31 woman in Christianity (whom Deesha Philyaw describes as “the Beyoncé of evangelicals” in the first line of her riveting debut novel The True Confessions of First Lady Freeman). Like Khadijah, the Proverbs 31 woman of the Bible was a virtuous and successful businesswoman whom her children and husband revere and for whom her presence is a blessing. As someone whose line name was Proverbs 31, I know intimately the misogynistic burden of this saintly, idealized woman in Christianity who—unlike Khadijah—wasn’t even based on a real woman but still did plenty of damage to real women who were expected to live up to her self-sacrificial standard. Khadijah was the Prophet Muhammad’s first convert to Islam and a major support to his mission. The imam needs Fatiha to know that her mother chose this name—and presumably the holy path of Khadijah—on purpose, for a purpose with which Fatiha should also align herself.
But we don’t see Khadijah choose her own name, or speak at all for herself, so we have to take the man’s word for her reasoning. All that we learn of Latif’s Khadijah is from flashbacks of her in service to Latif. Do we see her face? I don’t remember a clear shot of it, only of her hands, neck, torso—the parts necessary to caress Latif after a long day of killing, or to pray for his safety while he is away committing said killings. A disembodied woman is easy to weaponize and the imam speaks to Fatiha about Khadijah as if setting her up to take on this same role one day: wife of a holy warrior, his first believer, praying and healing his wounds.
Latif also sets his teen daughter up for this role, often leaving his newborn baby in her care as he does some pretty reckless, thoughtless things. The inciting incident that sets our hero on his path to restoring his faith in the wake of his wife’s untimely death is that the newborn won’t drink formula, sparking his desperate search throughout Houston, Texas for breastmilk. He leaves the baby with Fatiha while he does something else, which unintentionally begins the entanglement of him and his children in a holy war with Pastor Hwan (John Cho), an imam-murdering Korean Christian terrorist. This leads me back to my initial conclusion that this is a film about how much harder dads have it than mothers.
Because if Latif’s mysterious wife were still alive, he would’ve never had to have been running around the city trying to find breastmilk and getting into trouble in the first place; the mother would just make the breastmilk naturally. Women famously do not have any problems at all with breastmilk production or babies latching. Surely, the existence of the breastmilk clinic that Latif unsuccessfully tries to obtain breastmilk from only exists for men like him who have no nursing women around to feed babies </sarcasm>.
But on a serious note, yes, sometimes babies prefer breastmilk to formula in real life. Using this as a major plot point in a movie, however, should have a deeper meaning. But the meaning I’m picking up for why Latif chases down breastmilk like an elixir, like it’s ambrosia, feels heavy on the hotep in its symbolism: patriarchal and gender-essentialist in its pedestaling of nursing and motherhood as the ultimate expression of womanhood. Hotep or fauxtep ideology still thinks of women as subservient to men (think: people who say “divine feminine” or call women “womb-man”). But they can glorify cisgender women in their most vulnerable state of pregnancy and nursing because it’s evidence of men’s own fertility and a reinforcement of strict gender roles and responsibilities. It’s out of order for Latif to have to go in search of breastmilk so that’s what sparks all of his bigger problems.
The final straw is when Latif leaves his kids again to go on a risky mission and Fatiha reads to her little brother Qadir a famous hadith (oral history/anecdote) in Islam to comfort him as they worry about if and when their father will return. This is the hadith from which the writer-director Tariq chose the title of the film:
A person came to Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and asked, “Who among people is most deserving of my fine treatment?” He (ﷺ) said, “Your mother”. He again asked, ‘’Who next?” “Your mother”, the Prophet (ﷺ) replied again. He asked, “Who next?” He (the Prophet (ﷺ)) said again, “Your mother.” He again asked, “Then who?” Thereupon he (ﷺ) said, “Then your father.”
The little brother replies to his sister, “Dang. Dad’s cooked…he has to fill shoes three-times as big—” or something to that effect. And I wanted to pull out my own hair.
Already, this young boy has been conditioned to center a man, even when holy scriptures put three times as much emphasis on a woman.
And I’m not saying that active, present fathers don’t have a hard job; active, present parenting is tough. But most of the hardness of Latif’s job is self-inflicted. He leaves the baby with the teen girl when he should simply be watching the baby himself. When the teen allows a stranger who does sex work to breast feed the baby, he initially gets upset with the teen for not knowing better, and then decides to hunt the sex worker down himself for more of her breastmilk, despite the fact that: 1) she’s a stranger; and 2) she is in a high-risk, unregulated profession and diseases can transfer to babies via breastmilk. It’s not as if he were trapped with his children in a genocide in Gaza; he had options and time. Common sense would say to be a little bit more discerning about how you feed your baby. If he had not tracked down this specific woman, literally none of the danger he, his children and his mosque encounter afterwards would’ve happened.
I wonder what it means though that the only mother with a significant speaking role in the film is a danger to our male hero and his baby girl. A hint is in her name: Fugazi. Played by Tiffany Boone, Fugazi seems like she’s here to help, but her name is a word popularly known to mean fake, inauthentic, knock-off. It’s also a backronym from Mark Baker’s book Nam, about the Vietnam War: “Fucked Up, Got Ambushed, Zipped In [a body bag].” Her name is foreshadowing Latif’s future for trusting her. I’m not sure what Muslims call this, but we recovering Christians call this male flattening of women the Madonna-Whore Complex. In Tariq’s imagination, these are the only women who exist: Saintly anointed invisble Khadijah vs. the present-yet-evasive and dastardly jezebel sex worker Fugazi.
And Fatiha is stuck in the middle (which is ironic, because Fatiha means “beginning.” Perhaps her name is simply Tariq foreshadowing where she will end up on the Madonna-Whore spectrum). At the beginning of the film, as she’s grieving her mother’s mysterious death, Latif catches Fatiha watching what I can only guess is Teletubbies porn? He chastises her for it and they butt heads throughout the film as she flexes her independence and questions her faith in Allah—just as Latif does privately. Fatiha is the one who exposes the baby and her younger brother Qadir to Fugazi and a busload of other sex workers, where Qadir seems to be exposed to sexualized nudity, a form of child abuse and grooming that subsequently becomes joke fodder for some really gross adults in Latif’s life. Fatiha is on a corrupting path and will have to make a choice about the kind of woman she wants to become by the end of the film.
Fatiha must make this grown-up choice over the course of the film and not, say, while she’s off at college or something, because she is a prime example of an adultified girl child. Her father continuously puts her in positions to care for his baby and young son, making her take the place of his dead wife. When Latif upsets Qadir by talking against the power of prayer, it’s Fatiha that must go to her brother to comfort and pray with him, even as she has her own doubts. She’s already learned to put aside her thoughts and feelings for the benefit of men and boys because her father can’t manage to regulate his own emotions in the presence of his children. As a dad, he weaponizes incompetence as much as the swords he swings.
In yet another instance of poor and dangerous decision-making, Latif decides to skip town with his children in order to hide from his assassin boss Mike Mahmoudi (Ramy’s Laith Nakil) when things go wrong, which makes the boss reasonably believe that Latif has betrayed him. Latif’s grand plan is to abscond to Mexico…with a fresh baby? If he doesn’t have breastmilk for the child, I know good and well he doesn’t have a passport for her. Dads do not have it three times as hard, as the film suggests. This dad is three-times less competent. (I may have just stumbled upon his wife’s mysterious cause of death.)
Which brings me to his final act. I get that Ali trained with swords for a year to prepare to play Blade in the Marvel reboot of the franchise, and that once Marvel unceremoniously shelved Blade, Ali and Tariq built Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother around Ali’s new sword-fighting skills. However, Blade was about vampire-hunting. It was a fantasy-action film where his choice of weapon made sense for killing vampires. In this new, non-fantasy film, we don’t know why swords are his weapon of choice, though we do know that he dislikes guns because he forbids his children to play games with toy guns. But building action around sword-fighting in 2026 requires Latif to bring a knife to a machine gunfight.
And again, if that’s what you want to do, fine. But make it make sense! Latif goes into a den of thieves and murderers with no plan for victory and for no discernible reason. There’s no strategy, no stealth—he just drives up to the front gate and walks in, swords swinging, like he wanted to die, like he expected to orphan his three children.
Reckless. Thoughtless. Careless. And Fatiha must pick up the pieces.
It’s on Fatiha to look after her younger siblings while also praying for the safety of her father who—I can’t emphasize this enough—took a knife to a gunfight. It’s on her to get on her knees to do intercessory prayer for a miracle. Fatiha, after all, also means “the opener / one who opens.” She is the gateway, the spiritual key, the Hail Mary, the deus ex machina, that Latif needs to survive. And, like Khadijah, Fatiha is praised for this. “Who you got praying for you?!” Pastor Hwan asks Latif, incredulously. Hwan may be a bigoted murderous demon, but the good Christian can recognize the evidence of a prayer warrior when he sees it. “My daughter,” Latif responds with pride, gratitude and a bit of disbelief. As if the hadith she recited to her brother was a final incantation, Fatiha has become her mother, her mother, her mother. The adultification of the Black girl child is complete.
As a filmmaker, Tariq is not unique in his dichotomous view of women and girls. Every day men wake up and make a movie that screams “I don’t see women as people, only obstacles or angels of my hero’s journey” — double when the women and girls are Black. But the Pakistani filmmaker’s dead spot in his vision for gender both amplifies and intersects with his dead spot on race, as well. Though Ali’s Latif attends a Black mosque with his family, he works at the behest of the non-Black Muslim Mike Mahmoudi, who directs Latif on who is a threat to the Muslim community, and who Latif must kill for pay. But the Muslim community is vast, with more than two billion people in the faith. And just like literally every community, there can be extreme anti-Blackness within it.
Even as (trigger-warning) Islamophobic bigots massacre people at a Black mosque, the Islamophobic bigots aren’t the core of the conflict in Your Mother. Instead, the battle stems from what happens when the interests of Black Muslims and non-Black Muslims conflict, as shown in the relationship between Latif and his non-Black boss. Latif wants to quit being an assassin; Mike acts as if he owns Latif like a slave—his own personal weapon for hire, to direct as he sees fit. But the racial dynamic of this conflict is never explicitly addressed.
Mike also expects Latif to defend and protect his non-Black nephew Hatty who cosplays in Black American hip hop culture while running the pornography studio where Fugazi is introduced to Latif’s children. And Latif obeys, long after he is under any requirement to do so; he risks his life and his children’s future for Hatty, while the assassin leaves the Black Muslims who are killed in the racist attack on their mosque largely unavenged. It’s just as disconcerting that the face of Southern evangelical Christian terrorism is a Korean man in this film as opposed to the white people who dominate the field in real life. Needless to say, the inherent racial dynamics simmering on the fringes of the conflict between the Black, Arab and Korean men feel underdeveloped, unexplored and unexplained.
This contributes to a feeling of deep dissatisfaction by the end. When Latif ends up killing Muslims over what was ultimately a misunderstanding, it’s disappointing and a bit sad compared to who gets to live. All the wrong people die in this film, and the resolution with the main villain feels rushed and incredible—as in, too extraordinary and improbable to be believed. I’d be willing to eat the idea that the sword and shield of Allah can defeat any slings and arrows, but at least slow down and set the table.
Your Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother may not have been the Blade movie people were hoping for, but it is likely the closet one we’ll get from Tariq and Ali. I’m glad the duo were able to stick it to Marvel head Kevin Feige for fumbling the bag; I’m glad they were able to create something original without the shackles Marvel puts on its creators (and with Marvel’s resources!), to bring their own vision of a Black, sword-fighting Muslim father and vigilante to life. But far too often in a man’s vision, Black women and girls get flattened or erased on the journey—even when the hadiths of Muhammad remind them three times not to.
Stay watchin’,
Brooke
Enjoyed this piece? Tip your writer!
Related:
-

The Best (and the Rest) of TIFF 2026
This was my third year of #BGWatTIFF (Black Girl Watching at the Toronto International Film Festival), my favorite fest of all the fests! I don’t know if it’s just Toronto in early fall, which is the perfect, crisp weather, or that my schedule is usually jam packed morning to night with fantastic films from all over the world, but TIFF makes me feel so hopeful about cinema. (ICYMI, watch Colman Domingo’s powerful TIFF panel on how he and the filmmakers of Sing, Sing crafted a fee structure that paid everyone the exact same rate and gave every person who made the film possible, from the PA’s to the number one guy Domingo a financial stake in the film’s success. It was my favorite experience of TIFF, even above the films!) Here’s my dispatch from the fest.
A note: I of course saw Mahershala Ali’s Your, Mother, Your Mother, Your Mother, which comes out this Friday, Sept. 28, so I will have a separate review of that film this week. The other is David Oyelowo’s Clarissa, the Lagos-set adaptation of Virginia Woolf’s Mrs. Dalloway, which comes out in December, so I’ll hold my review of that film til closer to the release date. Stay tuned!
All That She Wants
My girl Annie Murphy (of Schitt’s Creek and Kevin Can F*ck Himself fame) stars in a much-deserved rom-com. Set in Toronto, All That She Wants features Murphy as Emma an “aging” dancer at age 39(!!) who falls in like with a younger man, a grad student that she later discovers she used to babysit. After a tumultuous relationship that stole her twenties, she’s determined not to stunt the young man’s growth over a silly one-night stand, but their unexpected connection drives him to convince her that she can have everything she wants in life—and he can help. It’s also a sister story, with Girls star Zosia Mamet as Emma’s younger, married sister as Emma’s main support system and a mother-daughter story, with Christine Baranski (y’all know her from The Good Wife but I know her from The War, iykyk!) playing the overbearing mother whose judgment Emma fears. It’s sweet, it’s funny, it’s a Christmas romance that’s actually romantic. And with all such fare, I think of the Christmas romance connoisseur—my mother—and ask myself, would she like this? For All That She Wants, I think the answer is a resounding yes. Once this film actually gets distribution (fingers crossed!), I’ll report back on her thoughts. Hopefully it winds up on Netflix in time for the holidays.
Elsinore
This is my favorite film from TIFF, by a mile! Andrew Scott (perhaps best known as Hot Priest from Fleabag) is a marvel in this surprisingly hilarious drama based on the true story of award-winning actor Ian Charleson. In 1989, famous thespian Daniel Day Lewis walked off stage in the first five minutes of his starring role in Hamlet, leaving Charleson this dream role: to play Hamlet at the National Theatre in London. But just as he is offered the opportunity of a lifetime, he receives what was then a death sentence, an AIDS diagnosis. (Please note: this film is a period piece; Thanks to medical advancements in science and vaccines, many people live long, healthy lives with HIV today.)
As Hamlet famously wrestles with life and death — “To be, or not to be? That is the question!”— so does Charleson, fighting to live long enough to see his dream through against the advice of his doctor (played by another Fleabag favorite, Olivia Colman). What is life, or living, he asks, if you can’t do the thing you love? Charleson’s fight for quality over quantity of life will resonate with any artist watching their industry crumble around them who still chooses art anyway. It’s a reminder that there is a power and a purpose in the crafting of art that our tech overlords and AI slop makers couldn’t even fathom. Yes, this film is for the artists, but it’s also much more specific. Like last year’s tear-jerker Hamnet, Elsinore drives home how timeless, ageless and perfect the story of Hamlet really is. Whether a grieving mother in the 1600s or a beloved actor fighting through the AIDS pandemic in the 1980s, or anyone in film/TV today as our cowardly politicians collude with billionaires to merge studios and destroy what’s left of our industry—the story of Hamlet continues to speak to the moment. (Mainly, “conscience does make cowards of us all.”)
Scott gives his best performance to date, and I hope Elsinore drives more people to Charleson’s story, to Hamlet, and to the refuge of the arts in general.
Elsinore will be in theaters on November 20 just in time for the holidays.
Paid subscribers can download Hamlet below, and you should!!
Future Tense
This was the most challenging film for me at the festival. I began my watch intrigued by the premise: Cape Town, South Africa in a near-future hellscape where the wealthy (mostly white people) can time-travel back to the past and vacation in a time before colonialism fucked everything up. A young Black South African man tells his white Afrikaner situationship that he won a trip to the past in a lottery and invites her along for what should be a one-night romantic getaway. Tensions arise when the couple discover that a Black South African man and an Afrikaner woman might have different desires for what a trip to the past should entail. The film plays with time throughout, jumping backwards and forwards from the couple’s first date into their future. There’s a beautiful moment where an Indigenous person laments what colonization stole and why the fight continues. And as someone whose first novel Book of Addis: Cradled Embers wrestles with this same idea of going back to the past in order to have a better future for people oppressed in the present, I was willing to let a rushed third act slide. It’s the attempt of the Black man to wrestle—even at the risk of failure—that I enjoyed. That was back when I thought a Black South African man wrote and directed the film, though.
After watching, I found out that it was written and directed by a white South African woman. That complicates my original feelings about the film. In retrospect, it feels like a practice in colonialism rather than liberation for a white South African woman to be exploring the experience of what someone whose oppression she benefits from, inserting herself inside of a Black oppressed man’s psyche and asking but what about meeeeeee? if you get your freedom, what will that mean for meeeeeee? And now I’m just retroactively annoyed at all the times the story shifts from being about the Black man’s search for liberation to how dangerous and threatening it feels for the white woman and what her role in all this should be.
There’s a moment where the Black man is explaining about Africans’ understanding of time as only the past and present, circular, without future. It feels like this concept would’ve been more central to the film and the filmmaking if a Black South African who had a more intimate understanding of that cultural and scientific belief had written and directed a time-travel film on this topic. There were many little moments like that one, germs of ideas that in other hands could’ve really been fleshed out. I wish white filmmakers would do their own wrestling with what a lust for dominating and controlling the entire planet has stolen from them too. Where humans thrived for tens of thousands of years, in harmony and balance with all life, it took white supremacist, capitalist, colonial patriarchy a couple of centuries to utterly destroy the entire planet beyond repair. Go wrestle with that, and let Black people tell our own stories. In the end, the Black man’s failures, isolation and lack of community as opposed to the white woman’s abundance of community and hopeful future awaiting her feel like a violent lack of imagination. But, consider the source.
Future Tense doesn’t yet have distribution.
Neverman
What happens to queer activists who manage to live to old age? Neverman ponders this question through trans woman activist Lucia (Justin Vivian Bond) who lost her wife and daughter years ago over her decision to continue dangerously advocating for trans and queer lives after the daughter was born. Now at the end of her life and estranged from her daughter, the activist can’t even fight for herself, as she’s forced into a nursing home that does not affirm her gender as her Alzheimer’s worsens. It’s incredibly tragic with a confusing ending. But Bond and her younger counterpart Eva Everett Irving are fantastic as Lucia in the past and present, as the story weaves throughout her memories and her reality. There’s a fantastic transition in the opening of the film that I’ll never forget.
There’s also a nude sex scene between an old trans and queer couple and I’ve never seen anything like that on screen—not Nicole Kidman and some young guy in Babygirl, but two old people together. And trans and queer? Never. So I’d call Neverman revolutionary for that alone. It is quieter in its intentions about finding life joy, love, sex and meaning, even at the end, even when you can’t remember yourself. Neverman doesn’t curl all the way over in the end; I would’ve liked to have seen more of the conflict between why a cisgender queer mother felt less inclined to continue the activism that connected her to a trans woman activist in the first place only to leave Lucia to fight on alone. But it’s worth a watch, if only to spark thought about how we treat our queer elders and what we owe them.
Neverman does not yet have distribution.
Prima Facie
This Cynthia Erivo film was a real let down. Named after the legal term that means “on its face” — i.e., something obvious/apparent, something sufficient to be considered a fact in court— Prima Facie follows Erivo as Tessa, a high-powered defense attorney in London who successfully defends male rapists, reaming their female victims on the stand with satisfaction. When the tables turn and she becomes a victim of a rapist, all of the tactics she once deployed for her clients are used on her. “He is a bastard defense attorney,” she says of her rapist at the police station. “And so am I.” That’s about as introspective as Tessa gets. But I don’t buy her naiveté.
At several points after the rape, she repeats: “I used to believe in the law,” which is why she became a barrister, and also, presumably, why she defended men accused of rape. She taught her protégé that it didn’t matter whether her clients were guilty or innocent, that it was for the legal system to decide. So every time a woman cried after Tessa’s cross-examination (a Black woman, at that, in the opening case of the film), and every time a man cheered smugly and thanked her when he got acquitted, it never once occurred to her that the law wasn’t working as designed, protecting abusers and traumatizing victims who dare come forward, prima facie? I don’t buy it. And because she never wrestles with her earlier “belief” in the law and her actual complicity in the legal system that failed her, her big speech condemning the legal system falls flat. You’re an agent of that system, boo. What’s good for the goose aint good for the gander?
A frustrating watch. But there was one moment when I cheered; Erivo wears horrid Tyler Perry wigs throughout the film—sometimes with that barrister’s white powdered wig on top. After a pivotal scene, Tessa’s mother throws the worst of the soggy mops into the trash, and for a shining moment, there is peace.
Oddly enough, the film reminded me of Zendaya’s The Drama, a thought experiment in search of a movie: wouldn’t it be ironic if the rape defense attorney became a victim? Which is fine and usually how movie ideas start. But they need more flesh to become real. Prima Facie just doesn’t have enough meat on the bones. It also reminded me of my ire for Promising Young Woman, in that it’s intent on punishing women complicit in patriarchy while letting the male perps walk free. Sure, get the complicit people, but can we also get the main guys?? For once?? In a made-up, imaginary movie??
Trigger warning for a rape scene; I never think those are necessary, but perhaps because the rapist isn’t a stranger jumping out of the bushes, but a man that Tessa is dating, there is value in seeing how most rapes happen—someone you know who intentionally skates the line of plausible deniability.
Sony Pictures bought distribution rights and it will premiere in the UK in November.
The Julia Set
Well, I’d watch The Julia Set again before I ever watched One Battle After Another, so this college drama is a step up for its star Chase Infiniti. Still, it’s a low bar. In the film, Infinity plays a Black girl math genius named Julia who learned to shrink herself at home due to the survivor’s guilt she feels for her brother having Down’s Syndrome. When her nepo baby teaching assistant recognizes her talents and invites her into an elite math group at the school, she’ll have to confront her willingness to shrink in order to soar. Infiniti proves once again to be a very capable, very natural actress; I never see her trying to be Julia, though the character’s immature, naive choices are maddening, it is clear that Infiniti’s Julia believes in them.
Chloe Bailey plays her best friend-hype woman, which only works because both actresses are Black women; it could’ve gotten very problematic very quickly otherwise. Though Bailey could’ve used a few more takes earlier in the film, she eases into the role about midway through and becomes a delight. I can’t say the same for the movie itself. The Julia Set means well; writer-director Niki Byrne wants to explore the rare topic of female genius (and the complicating intersections of race and relationship status within it). And Alex Dillard is a scene-stealer in the role of Julia’s brother. But at times the drama feels both underwritten and cartoonishly overdone.
Julia would truly have to hate herself to endure what she does, and youthful naiveté is just not enough of an excuse for the lack of character development in the script. Who hasn’t been a bright-eyed, genius freshman dating a deeply insecure, abusive older student? There’s lore behind those choices and finding that right balance between surprising but ultimately inevitable behavior is missing. I hate to say it, since I know this is Julia’s core trauma, but I wish she would shrink again and that the story could be about her far more interesting and funny brother.
The Julia Set does not yet have distribution, but with a stacked cast including Nina Hoss (wasted!) and Gillian Anderson (double wasted!!), I’m sure that’s coming soon. In the meantime, watch Nina Hoss in a better movie, one of my 2025 favorites, Hedda, on Prime Video instead.
The Secret Lives of Baba Segi’s Wives
Nollywood has come a long way over the years, so if you’ve been sleeping on the largest production of films outside of Hollywood, stop that! The Secret Lives of Baba Segi’s Wives has a budget, great actors, and beautiful cinematography while staying culturally true to its soapy roots. It feels like an oral history of a family, a microcosm of Lagos and the ways patriarchy destroys women and girls and hurts men and boys too. Based on the popular novel of the same name, Daniel Oriahi’s film was a hit at TIFF, with the premiere screening met with riotous applause and plenty of laughs while navigating some seriously traumatic circumstances. Come for the feminist exploration of women and girls in a polygamous household. Stay for a total deconstruction of toxic masculinity, with book-ending scenes of a father teaching his son how to be a man, and how not to be one.
TW for violence against women and girls, in all its forms.
The Secret Lives of Baba Segi’s Wives will be in theaters in Nigeria on December 4. Hopefully it will get US/UK distribution soon.
Voices
What profits a man to gain the whole world and lose his soul? If any film sums up how nasty and cutthroat you must be to succeed in the entertainment industry, it’s Voices. A stunning musical debut from director Deanté Gray, Voices follows Jordan, a young Black man in 1967 Detroit who is determined to be a famous singer. Just as he’s fired from his bellhop job at a Black motel for focusing more on music than the job, still in uniform, he gets a fated chance to assist a music manager with his bags who’s just checked in. The manager further hires Jordan to assist his rising-star act The Harmony Brothers for the day, as they prepare for a big performance that night for Motown Records. When an accident ensues, Jordan starts plotting how he might perform in their place and win his own contract with Motown. Moving between black and white and color picture, using film dissolves as transitions between reality and Jordan’s fantasies—or perhaps his harrowing future—Gray and his writers Sam Buckner III and Charlie T. Savage tell a thrilling, frustrating and compelling story about longing for fame as the root of all evil.
Voices doesn’t yet have distribution, but fingers crossed for this fascinating film.
Ziwe: Wanda Sykes & Hasan Piker
I don’t watch Ziwe’s YouTube show You’d Be an Iconic Guest in the wild. The gotcha journalism with controversial figures is not really my kind of comedy. And once disgraced, fraudulent congressman George Santos gagged her on her own platform (“What can we do to get you to go away?” she asked him. “Stop booking me for gigs,” he responded. “But you can’t. Because people want the content.”) I’ve not seen the value in the format. But, the first day of TIFF was slow and watching two unseen episodes followed by a rooftop party seemed like a good way to ease into the fest.
The first ep. was with Wanda Sykes, my fellow HU alumna, who also coincidentally gave the commencement speech at my high school graduation. She’s hilarious on the HBO show The Other Two, but I don’t really watch anything else she’s in. Ziwe’s barbs were about Wanda being married to a white woman and having two white children, therefore being the only Black person in her house. “I take care of white people. You got me!” Wanda says.
The second episode is with Hasan Piker. Beyond knowing that Hasan Piker was the right-wing’s latest leftists boogeyman, I knew nothing about the man. I follow Black leftist politics and none of them have needed to cite Piker for anything so he was not on my radar. Apparently he is a white nepo baby who recycles Black and brown leftist politics without citation, so naturally he has become a huge success. I’m not sure he understood the format of the show, he was not a match for Ziwe. But he definitely humiliated liberal hack Symone Sanders on her own platform by saying basic things Black leftists have said for generations that Sanders pretended to have never heard before, so I guess that’s something.
*****Paid subscribers can watch the uncomfortable video Q&A with Ziwe being interviewed by an unprepared Variety reporter from TIFF here:
Stay watchin’,
Brooke
-

Dangerous Art: Macklemore’s Stand, and Colman Domingo’s Revolutionary Film
As I was returning from the 51st Toronto International Film Festival this week—my favorite film festival, and my third representing Black Girl Watching—Macklemore got kicked off of Ed Sheeran’s global tour for saying “Free Palestine.” Now, I do not listen to Macklemore or Ed Sheeran. I had no idea they were on tour. And now I am a subject-matter expert on the rousing speech Macklemore gave for Palestinian liberation during his opening act, and on Ed Sheeran’s sniveling cowardice, folding to pressure from zionist billionaire and Epstein Files member Robert Kraft to kick Macklemore off the tour.
As I arrived in Toronto for the festival last week, I had seen former blackfisher Pink crying about how the words “Free Palestine” made her feel unsafe (the darndest things make white women feel “unsafe” and it’s usually Black and brown people who have to suffer for it. I’m sure the slogans of the anti-slavery movement in America would’ve made her clutch her pearls too). And she got her wish to have Macklemore excommunicated from the stadium tour led by stadium owner Kraft and his Epstein Class cronies. But I don’t believe it was the phrase “Free Palestine,” that had them all shook. These two shows that Macklemore opened for Sheeran were played before an audience of 100,000 people per show. And they were all cheering, crying, chanting along with Macklemore that Palestine would be free. The zionist spell that has obscured their injustice of stealing Palestinian land, genociding the Palestinian people and ethnically cleansing Palestine for more than 70 years is lifting.
And now, thanks to the zionist fear, bullying and censorship of art, Ed Sheeran has lost his touring band and every other opening act who quit in solidarity with Palestine, and all credibility. A message that could’ve been contained to a few hundred thousand people over ten shows, has now exploded to millions of people and global news headlines for more than a week talking about the zionist genocide of Palestine and the waning power that zionists wield to silence free speech of the oppressed.
People have seen with their own eyes the IOF destroy Palestinian olive orchards, all Palestinian universities, books, ancient artifacts and architecture in an attempt to erase the evidence of thousands of years of Palestinian culture and life. People have seen Palestinian babies blown from their mothers’ wombs—I have seen these images over the past three years of live-streamed genocide, and I will never get them out of my mind. I will never un-hear the voice of Hind Rajab, the five year old girl whom the IOF slaughtered with 355 bullets. So when Macklemore memorialized Hind and the Columbia University protestors who overtook their genocide funding institution in protest of her murder with the song “Hind’s Hall,” and performed it with images from the genocide in Gaza to 200,000 people over two shows on tour, he reminded me of what Toni Morrison said: “Art is dangerous.”
It’s dangerous because it pierces through the consciousness of an audience and stays with them, impacting their emotions and their actions, consciously and unconsciously. Art is a weapon. How you wield it and who you wield it for matters. Macklemore chose to wield his weapon on behalf of the oppressed, genocided and ethnically cleansed Palestinian people. Ed Sheeran chose to wield his weapon against the oppressed, on behalf of a billionaire in the Epstein files. There is no such thing as apolitical art. All artists must choose, whether we like it or not. And the people will be the judge of it.
The Palestinian poet Refaat Alareer said in his final interview before being targeted and executed by the IOF: “I am an academic, probably the toughest thing I have at home is an Expo marker. But if the Israelis invade, if they charge at us, open door to door to massacre us, I’m going to use that marker, throw it at the Israeli soldiers, even if that is the last thing I will be able to do.” His art was dangerous to Empire and it cost him his life. Their fear of the power of our art is a matter of life and death, not mere comfort. That is the real sacrifice. Macklemore using his white male privilege in an art form he co-opted from Black people is literally the least he can do and it has cost him, but it will not cost him his life. For those of us within the belly of the beast, those of us who sit at the intersection of marginalizations—race, class, gender, ability, sexuality, geography—the cost will always be higher. Yet, that is the artists’ charge: to throw our markers, our films, our songs, our poems, our literature at Empire for the benefit of the people. For our own liberation.
Which brings me back to TIFF. In 2023, Colman Domingo’s film Sing, Sing premiered at the festival and was immediately my favorite of the year. Based on a true story, this film followed incarcerated men at the Sing Sing prison who participate in a performing arts program as a form of therapy in the high-stress conditions of the prison system. Formerly incarcerated men and graduates of the arts program starred as themselves alongside Domingo to tell a beautiful story of what art as a weapon can do, piercing through the cold concrete of our modern-day slavery institutions and giving hope and an outlet to men in chains to be free in their minds.
But what’s most remarkable about Domingo’s film is not just the story they told, but how they told it. Director Greg Kwedar and his producing and writing partner Clint Bentley joined Domingo on stage at this year’s TIFF for a panel on how they paid every single person who contributed to their film Sing, Sing equally—from the production assistant, to their A-list number one on the call sheet, Mr. Colman Domingo himself. Every person who contributed to Sing, Sing also got equity in the film, so when the film makes a profit, they make a profit too. On a usual film set, this would be extraordinary. On a film set with a majority cast of people who have worked for slave wages in prison, this is an extra radical act, a scream in the face of the dehumanizing prison industrial complex. It’s a damning act in an industry that thrives on the exploitation of workers, and the assumption that “stars” should get millions while the people who keep the sets running should just be happy to be there.
A film is never solely the product of the director or the star; it is the result of so many hardworking people who never get the credit for their work and can struggle financially while the films they work on make hundreds of millions around the world. The brainchild of Kwedar and Bentley, The Ethos Model of filmmaking is something they’ve now done successfully on two award-winning films, Jockey and Sing, Sing. And the filmmakers hope it is catching.
Watchers, I bawled my eyes out throughout this beautiful conversation moderated by Domingo, in a packed auditorium of cheering filmmakers. I felt more hope for the survival of human, ethical filmmaking than I ever have before. Their ethos of equal pay and equity in filmmaking is what I long to achieve. I long to meet producers, actors and other filmmakers who want to make this kind of dangerous art, for the people, by the people; for our collective liberation. I want to work with people who believe that it is possible for us all to succeed, and that there is a greater purpose, a dangerous purpose to the art that we make — and a tremendous responsibility.
Sing, Sing was snubbed in the Best Picture category of the Oscars, even though it was absolutely one of the best pictures of the year. I strongly believe the Hollywood Machine found Sing, Sing too dangerous to reward as a production due to the producers’ radical ideology of pay equity. What if other filmmakers and A-listers start banding together for equal pay?! Won’t someone think of the billionaires’ bottom line?! How can they control us if having more money than someone else is no longer a motivating factor?! Making dangerous art on behalf of the people will cost you something. But the reward and the new world the artists will build where we can all create and thrive is well worth the cost.
My Black Girl Watching podcast Another Possible World is my way of trying to connect with these kinds of like-minded filmmakers, to talk about the revolutionary ways we can use our art to free people and ourselves, without falling victim to the traps of this industry and the pressures of the Epstein class who seek our capitulation and control. I’ve been trying to get Black woman producer of Sing, Sing, Monique Walton on the podcast since its inception, so fingers crossed that that will happen. Until then, paid subscribers can enjoy this 45 minute video conversation from TIFF between Domingo, Bentley and Kwedar on how they equitably paid their workers to bring this film to life below the paid subscriber line.
Stay tuned for more dispatches from TIFF and stay watchin’!
Brooke
UPGRADE TO WATCH:
